Bird of Roses:

     Could they have put any more restrictions on how this guy has to die to get his effect?  It seems a tad ridiculous, but with his effect, I suppose I understand.  Being able to pull out 2 tuners from your deck is a very exploitable effect (Diva, Cat, etc...) as we've seen over the last few formats.  Obviously, the biggest draw back for this guy is that your opponent is going to read the card, and then most likely, not attack him whilst in face-up attack position (book of moon or enemy controller anyone?) or just use some sort or removal on him.  So this card can either make your opponent squirm for a turn, or force their hand and use that smashing or brain control they've been holding onto.  Should they actually attack it, then you get to bring out a couple Cherry Inmatos or Nettles.  It's too bad we don't have Naturia Cosmobeet yet as it's name is the greatest name of a Yugioh card ever, and could also be summoned from the effect of Bird.  But Cherry Inmato works nicely, as it allows you to set up even more plays should your opponent destroy those Inmatos as well, because they too can special summon Inmato monsters from the deck.  If anything, this card gives plants another 1800 atk beater to use that actually has an effect that makes it worth considering.

Traditional:  2.0
Advanced:   3.0  (would have been higher without stupid destruction requirements)