Have Magic News?  Send it to


Card Price Guide

Featured Writers
The Dragon's Den
Rumblings From The Ass
The Heretic's Sermon
Through The Portal 
Deviations from the Norm
"Extended" Warranties 
The Grim Tutor

MTG Fan Articles
Single Card Strategy 
Deck Tips & Strategies 
Tourney Reports 
Peasant Magic 
Featured Articles

Deck Garage
Aaron's School

Message Board 
Magic League

Contact Us

Pojo's Book Reviews



Sending the Wrong Signals

Now, don't let the title get taken out of context. For those of you looking for dating tips, you've stopped in the wrong place (Unless you are looking for polite gamer chicks attending tournaments).

I have gotten several e-mails from readers that wonder what proper etiquette is in certain situations. Some players seem confused on what to do. Others seem really put off by how their opponents react to certain things. I figured I would once again do the Magic online community a favor and cover a few different situations. After all, we all want to send the best possible signals. Really, who wants to look bad, or seem like an ass to their opponent? Hopefully, I can help you keep from doing just that.

These are not the final word on how to deal with these situations. These are just recommendations of how to handle these problems that I have pieced together from different players and small surveys.

Situation #1: Watching your opponent take a mulligan.

Should you pump the fist or show excitement as your opponent mulligans? I say it depends. This is a situation where you can do so playfully and it shouldn't be too much harm. However, to be honest, any good player will tell you that it is highly possible to win from a six card or five card hand. It happens all the time. When you think about it, it would be more worth it to pump the fist if your opponent kept the bad hand and didn't mulligan. I say it isn't really right to get excited as it does make you look slightly less experienced. However, if the situation is tight and it's a must when game, it's ok.

Situation #2: What to do when your opponent is manascrewed.

This is really tough. Some people really get bent out of shape over manasrew. They donít understand thatís itís a part of the game and sometimes its going to happen. The truth of the matter is better players and deck builders don't experience manascrew as often as lower level players and deck builders. However, it happens even to them. I saw just offer some words of encouragement to your opponent. Wish them to draw land. Be encouraging. Also, don't rub it in. Just cast more spells and take advantage so you can end it quickly. No one wants to have their manascrew drawn out, especially when they have no chance of winning. Also, I wouldn't recommend the stating the typical "good game" and extending the hand. I would say to say something more along the lines of, "Man, would have been nice for you to draw land in the deciding game," or " Sucks to lose a match like that." This seems much better than the typical "good game" to me.

Situation #3: Dealing with opponentís topdeck rituals.

I think it's quite ok to have some of your topdeck rituals. When you need to draw a key card off the top rope, having a ritual can make the wait a little more fun. I think antics to entertain the crowd are "cute." I also think anything that can add to the overall entertainment value is worth it. However, there should be some guidelines to follow. If you choose to thump, knock, or use the ever-popular WWF Elbow on your deck, do it lightly. I have been witness to two incidents in recent history that rocked the table and moved items in three matches being played at a table. Just for the record, if this ever happens in my store, I would definitely issue some unsportsmanlike conduct warnings. However, rubbing the deck, chanting, calling on the gods, etc, should all be perfectly ok if they are done in good taste. I also recommend making a happy face or sad face before revealing your card to your opponent for added flavor. From the opposite end of the table, just sit back and enjoy it. Topdecking is a fun aspect of the game, so enjoy it.

Situation #4: Talking to players in other matches.

This can be VERY annoying. I personally try not to talk to anyone playing unless I have to. It's great to talk to your opponent, just keep it friendly. Don't yell across the room to your teammate asking how they are doing. You bother other players and re more than likely destroying the concentration of your friend. Also, if you are being a spectator of a match, do just that. Stand there and spectate. Wise men still seem to believe that silence is golden. There will be plenty of time for talk and details between rounds and after the tournament. Plus if you aren't talking during the match the suspicions of cheating/helping are always reduced.

Situation #5: Griping about cards.

If you lose a match to a "bad" card, how truly bad was it? Many players will walk around stating that certain cards are good or bad, but they are just parroting what they have read or have been told. Ask them why, and they aren't even sure. Then they try to guess and have the most skewed logic ever. The truth is, more players need to be open minded. Also, a lot of players have the idea that they just SHOULDN'T lose to certain other players. This is definitely not the issue. Anyone can beat anyone else on any given day. Just deal with it. If a card beats you, it beats you. Gripe all you want, but the player that won isn't going to hear it, so you are just wasting your breath.

Situation #6: The what if.

This is always one of the most fun things to talk about. How many of you have beaten a player so bad he had no possible way to win? Yet, when you went to pack up your things they stop you and say something along the lines of, "You know...had I drawn (insert card name here) I would have won that match." Then you sit there and try to formulate a way that you would have lost. Usually they were wrong. More often than not, I hear this from inexperienced players. I also think that this makes you look like an inexperienced (read as: bad) player. That's not to say that sometimes these situations don't come up. There are many times that you just miss topdecking the winner. However, when you give the "what if" after every game or every match, you lose all your credibility.

Now, let me say here that these are all the possible things that can make some one look bad. I just think that this will help people give of better images by following these guidelines. Also, you have to remember if everyone follows similar rules and etiquette the entire events can become a lot better.

The participants in a tournament play a huge part in the experiences that people draw from an event. It takes more than one group or one person to make an event fun. However, just two or three bad apples might wreck it for everyone.

Remember that no one wants to send bad signals.

No red lights.

Just green lights.

Until next time,

DeQuan Watson
a.k.a. PowrDragn




Copyright 2001 Pojo.com


Magic the Gathering is a Registered Trademark of Wizards of the Coast.
This site is not affiliated with Wizards of the Coast and is not an Official Site.